• Dr. Riley B. Montgomery 1919-1920 — Student Pastor
• Arthur Wake 1920-1924 — Pastor
• O. F. Sherwood 1925-1927 — Student Pastor
• J. T. Watson 1928-1930 — Pastor
• John R. Sloan 1930-1934 — Pastor
• Randolph White 1935-1943 — Pastor
• J. T. Meadows 1943-1950 — Pastor
• John H. Knibb, Jr. – 1950 — Student Pastor
• Don Scott – 1950-1951 — Student Pastor
• John H. Knibb, Jr. 1951-1956 — Pastor
• Dr. Raymond P. Morgan – 1956-1957 — Supply Minister
• David P. Cheverton – 1957-1961 — Pastor
• Dr. Joe T. Lindsoe – 1961-1980 — Pastor
• Dr. Richard Lawton – 1980-1981 — Pulpit Exchange
• Roland W. Jones 1981-1988 — Pastor
• Virgil Lilly – 1988-1989 — Interim Pastor
• Glenn E. Clements – 1989-1996 — Pastor
• John Colatch – 1990-1991 — Supply
• Arthur Beam – 1996-1997 — Interim Pastor
• Virgil R. Knipp – 1997- 2005 — Pastor
• Dr. Jim Dickerson – 2005 — Interim Pastor
• Jody Johnson – 2005-2010 — Pastor
• Dr. Jim Dickerson – 2010-2011 — Interim Pastor
• Matthew S. Ricks – 2011-Present — Pastor

• Thomas Law — Our Timothy
• Douglas Shearer — Our Timothy
• Alisha Bennett — Craig Springs Camp Director

Service Designation:

Pastor: Full time in residence minister
Interim Pastor: Full time non-resident minister
Supply: Sunday morning services only
Student Pastor: Student from Lynchburg College as supply
Exchange Pulpit: Pastors exchange residence for full time ministry

Note: Don Scott served for John Knibb’s final year in seminary while position was held for latter.

John Colatch, Chaplain at Ferrum College, served as supply while Glenn Clements served in Desert Storm War.